Supreme Court of India: Composition, Jurisdiction, Collegium & Landmark Cases for UPSC
UPSC Planner Editorial Team
Summary
A comprehensive UPSC guide to the Supreme Court of India: Articles 124 to 147, appointments and the Collegium, independence safeguards, jurisdiction, judicial review, and landmark judgments.
The Supreme Court of India is the apex constitutional court of the country. It interprets the Constitution, protects Fundamental Rights, resolves specified federal disputes, hears appeals, exercises judicial review and declares law binding on courts throughout India. For UPSC, the Supreme Court should not be studied merely as the highest appellate court. Its constitutional importance lies in the combination of judicial independence, constitutional interpretation, rights enforcement, federal adjudication and review of legislative and executive action.
Why This Chapter Matters
UPSC frequently tests distinctions such as:
- Supreme Court jurisdiction under Article 32 vs Article 131
- original jurisdiction vs appellate jurisdiction
- Article 136 Special Leave Petition vs ordinary constitutional appeal
- review petition vs curative petition
- Article 141 vs Article 142
- Court of Record vs contempt power
- constitutional text on appointments vs the Collegium system
- removal of a judge vs ordinary parliamentary removal
- Constitution Bench requirements
- Supreme Court vs High Court writ jurisdiction
- judicial review vs judicial activism
- advisory jurisdiction under Article 143
- retirement age of Supreme Court vs High Court judges
The key is to distinguish what the Constitution expressly provides, what Parliament regulates by law, and what has developed through Supreme Court jurisprudence.
Constitutional Framework: Articles 124 to 147
| Article | Constitutional subject |
|---|---|
| 124 | Establishment and constitution of Supreme Court |
| 125 | Salaries and conditions of Supreme Court judges |
| 126 | Appointment of Acting Chief Justice |
| 127 | Appointment of ad hoc judges |
| 128 | Attendance of retired judges |
| 129 | Supreme Court as a Court of Record |
| 130 | Seat of Supreme Court |
| 131 | Original jurisdiction in specified federal disputes |
| 132 | Appellate jurisdiction in constitutional cases |
| 133 | Appellate jurisdiction in civil matters |
| 134 | Appellate jurisdiction in criminal matters |
| 134A | Certificate for appeal to Supreme Court |
| 135 | Jurisdiction and powers of Federal Court exercisable by Supreme Court |
| 136 | Special leave to appeal |
| 137 | Review of judgments or orders |
| 138 | Enlargement of jurisdiction |
| 139 | Parliament may confer certain writ powers |
| 139A | Transfer of certain cases |
| 140 | Ancillary powers |
| 141 | Law declared by Supreme Court binding on all courts |
| 142 | Enforcement of decrees and orders and complete justice |
| 143 | President's power to consult Supreme Court |
| 144 | Civil and judicial authorities to act in aid of Supreme Court |
| 145 | Rules of Court and Constitution Benches |
| 146 | Officers, servants and expenses of Supreme Court |
| 147 | Interpretation for this Chapter |
Other provisions, especially Articles 13, 32, 50, 71, 121, 262, 368 and the Basic Structure doctrine, are also important for understanding the Court's constitutional role.
Establishment and Composition
Article 124 establishes the Supreme Court of India. The Constitution originally provided for:
- the Chief Justice of India, and
- not more than seven other judges
Parliament may by law increase the number of judges. Under the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956, as amended, the present sanctioned maximum strength is:
- Chief Justice of India
- 33 other judges
Therefore, the sanctioned strength is 34 judges including the Chief Justice of India.
π Prelims Trap: The number of Supreme Court judges is not permanently fixed at 34 by the Constitution. Parliament regulates the number by law.
Appointment of Supreme Court Judges
Article 124(2) provides the formal constitutional framework. A Supreme Court judge is appointed:
- by the President of India
- by warrant under the President's hand and seal
- following the constitutionally required process of consultation as interpreted through judicial decisions
The text of Article 124 and the judicially developed appointments system must be distinguished.
Qualifications for Appointment
Under Article 124(3), a person must be a citizen of India and satisfy at least one of the following:
- have been a judge of a High Court, or of two or more such courts in succession, for at least five years
- have been an advocate of a High Court, or of two or more such courts in succession, for at least ten years
- be, in the opinion of the President, a distinguished jurist
The Constitution therefore permits appointment from:
- the judiciary
- the Bar
- the distinguished jurist category
π Prelims Trap: Previous service as a High Court judge is not the only constitutional route to appointment to the Supreme Court.
Retirement Age
A Supreme Court judge holds office until attaining the age of: 65 years
This differs from a High Court judge, whose constitutional retirement age is 62 years.
A Supreme Court judge may also resign by writing addressed to the President.
Oath or Affirmation
Before entering office, a Supreme Court judge makes and subscribes an oath or affirmation according to the form prescribed in the Third Schedule. The oath includes commitments to:
- bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution
- uphold the sovereignty and integrity of India
- duly and faithfully perform judicial duties
- act without fear or favour, affection or ill-will
- uphold the Constitution and the laws
Post-Retirement Restriction
Article 124(7) provides that a person who has held office as a Judge of the Supreme Court shall not plead or act:
- in any court, or
- before any authority within the territory of India.
This is stricter than merely prohibiting practice before the Supreme Court itself.
Appointment of the Chief Justice of India
The Constitution does not expressly state that the senior-most Supreme Court judge must become the Chief Justice of India. Under the current appointment procedure, however, the convention is that the office should be filled by the: senior-most Judge of the Supreme Court considered fit to hold the office
The outgoing Chief Justice of India recommends the successor through the prescribed institutional process. The recommendation proceeds through the Union Government before appointment by the President.
π UPSC Distinction: Seniority in appointment of the CJI is a constitutional convention and institutional practice, not an express sentence in Article 124.
Evolution of the Collegium System
The word Collegium does not appear in the Constitution. The system evolved through Supreme Court judgments interpreting the constitutional requirement of consultation in judicial appointments.
First Judges Case: S.P. Gupta v. Union of India
In the First Judges Case, the Court's approach gave greater weight to the executive in the consultation process. The understanding of judicial appointments changed significantly through later judgments.
Second Judges Case: Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 1993
The Supreme Court reconsidered the appointments framework. The decision established judicial primacy in the appointment process and developed the Collegium principle. The opinion of the Chief Justice of India was treated as an institutional opinion rather than simply the personal opinion of one judge.
Third Judges Case: Presidential Reference, 1998
The Court further clarified the Collegium mechanism. For appointments to the Supreme Court, the institutional consultation came to involve: Chief Justice of India + four senior-most Supreme Court judges
This remains the core of the present Supreme Court Collegium structure for appointments to the Court.
Current Supreme Court Appointment Process
Under the present institutional process:
- a vacancy arises or is anticipated
- the Supreme Court Collegium considers candidates
- the Collegium records its recommendation
- the proposal moves through the Union Ministry of Law and Justice
- the Prime Minister advises the President
- the President makes the appointment
- the appointment is formally notified
For elevation to the Supreme Court, factors considered in the current process include matters such as:
- merit
- integrity
- seniority
- representation of High Courts
- judicial performance
- other relevant institutional considerations
The constitutional appointment itself remains an appointment by the President.
NJAC and the Ninety-Ninth Constitutional Amendment
Parliament enacted the Constitution (Ninety-Ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act to replace the Collegium system with the NJAC framework.
In Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 2015, the Supreme Court invalidated the Ninety-Ninth Amendment and the NJAC Act. The Collegium system consequently continued to govern higher judicial appointments. The judgment placed judicial independence at the centre of the constitutional analysis.
π Prelims Trap: NJAC is not the current appointment mechanism for judges of the Supreme Court.
Removal of a Supreme Court Judge
Article 124(4) provides a deliberately difficult removal mechanism designed to protect judicial independence. A Supreme Court judge may be removed only on the ground of:
- proved misbehaviour, or
- incapacity
The President may issue the removal order only after each House of Parliament passes an address supporting removal.
Special Majority for Removal
The address must be supported in each House separately by:
- a majority of the total membership of that House, and
- a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting
The parliamentary address must be presented to the President in the same session.
π UPSC Trap: The Constitution uses the language of removal of a judge. The expression "impeachment of a Supreme Court judge" is widely used, but Article 124 itself speaks of removal.
Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
Article 124(5) authorises Parliament to regulate the procedure for investigating and proving misbehaviour or incapacity. The Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 provides the statutory procedure.
A notice of motion must be signed by at least:
- 100 members of Lok Sabha, or
- 50 members of Rajya Sabha
The Speaker or Chairman, as applicable, may admit or refuse to admit the motion. If admitted, a three-member inquiry committee is constituted. The committee consists of:
- a person chosen from among the Chief Justice of India and other judges of the Supreme Court
- a Chief Justice of a High Court
- a distinguished jurist
The investigation stage must be distinguished from the later constitutional voting requirement in Parliament.
Safeguards for Judicial Independence
The Constitution contains several institutional protections.
Security of Tenure
A judge cannot be removed through an ordinary majority vote.
Difficult Removal Procedure
Removal requires the special majority under Article 124(4).
Salaries and Conditions
Article 125 protects salaries, allowances and relevant service conditions according to the constitutional and statutory framework. Conditions cannot ordinarily be varied to a judge's disadvantage after appointment, subject to constitutional provisions such as those relating to a Financial Emergency.
Charged Expenditure
Administrative expenses of the Supreme Court, including specified salaries and allowances, are charged upon the Consolidated Fund of India under Article 146.
Restriction on Parliamentary Discussion
Article 121 restricts discussion in Parliament regarding the conduct of a Supreme Court or High Court judge in the discharge of judicial duties except in connection with the constitutional removal process.
Post-Retirement Practice Restriction
Article 124(7) prohibits a former Supreme Court judge from pleading or acting before courts or authorities in India.
Administrative Control
The Constitution provides the Court with institutional control over its officers and servants within the Article 146 framework.
These protections collectively support judicial independence, but no single safeguard should be treated as the sole source of that independence.
Acting Chief Justice: Article 126
When:
- the office of Chief Justice of India is vacant, or
- the CJI is unable to perform the duties of office
the President may appoint another Supreme Court judge to perform the duties of Chief Justice. This is an Acting Chief Justice, not a permanent appointment as CJI.
Ad Hoc Judges: Article 127
If there is not a quorum of Supreme Court judges available to hold or continue a session, the Chief Justice of India may, with the constitutionally required consent and consultation, request a qualified High Court judge to sit temporarily as an ad hoc judge of the Supreme Court. An ad hoc judge enjoys the necessary jurisdiction, powers and privileges while so sitting.
Retired Judges: Article 128
Article 128 permits the attendance of eligible retired judges to sit and act as judges of the Supreme Court with the required consent. This provision is distinct from appointment of an ad hoc sitting High Court judge under Article 127.
Supreme Court as a Court of Record
Article 129 declares: The Supreme Court shall be a Court of Record.
The Article expressly includes the power to punish for contempt of itself. The Court's contempt power is therefore constitutionally recognised and does not arise only from ordinary legislation.
Contempt of Court
Contempt jurisdiction protects the administration of justice and authority of courts. Parliament has also enacted the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, but the Supreme Court's status and core contempt power are constitutionally grounded in Article 129.
For UPSC, distinguish:
- constitutional power under Article 129
- statutory regulation under contempt legislation
Seat of the Supreme Court: Article 130
The Supreme Court sits in Delhi. Article 130 also permits the Court to sit at another place or places if the Chief Justice of India, with the approval of the President, so appoints.
π Prelims Trap: The Constitution itself allows the possibility of sittings outside Delhi through the Article 130 mechanism.
Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court exercises several distinct forms of jurisdiction:
- original jurisdiction
- writ jurisdiction for Fundamental Rights
- appellate jurisdiction
- special leave jurisdiction
- review jurisdiction
- advisory jurisdiction
- transfer jurisdiction
- powers necessary for complete justice and enforcement of its orders
These should not be merged into a single general concept of "appeal".
Original Jurisdiction: Article 131
Article 131 gives the Supreme Court exclusive original jurisdiction over specified disputes involving governments. It covers disputes:
- between the Government of India and one or more States
- between the Government of India and one or more States on one side and one or more other States on the other
- between two or more States
The dispute must involve a question of law or fact on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends.
What Article 131 Does Not Mean
Article 131 is not a general forum for every dispute involving a State. It is a specialised federal jurisdiction involving the governmental parties specified in the Constitution. Certain disputes connected with pre-Constitution treaties, agreements and similar instruments are subject to constitutional exclusions.
Article 32: Fundamental Rights Jurisdiction
Article 32 guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights. The Supreme Court may issue appropriate:
- directions
- orders
- writs
including writs in the nature of:
- habeas corpus
- mandamus
- prohibition
- certiorari
- quo warranto
Article 32 is itself a Fundamental Right. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar famously emphasised its central importance to the constitutional scheme.
Article 32 vs Article 131
| Feature | Article 32 | Article 131 |
|---|---|---|
| Core purpose | Enforcement of Fundamental Rights | Federal governmental disputes |
| Who may approach | Person with appropriate rights claim, subject to jurisprudential rules | Specified governments |
| Nature | Rights enforcement | Federal original jurisdiction |
| Writs | Yes | Not the basis of jurisdiction |
| Exclusive to Supreme Court? | High Courts also have writ jurisdiction under Article 226 | Article 131 jurisdiction is vested in Supreme Court |
Supreme Court vs High Court Writ Jurisdiction
The Supreme Court's Article 32 jurisdiction is focused on Fundamental Rights. High Courts under Article 226 may issue writs:
- for enforcement of Fundamental Rights, and
- for any other purpose
Therefore High Court writ jurisdiction is constitutionally wider in subject matter. This does not make High Courts superior to the Supreme Court. It reflects a difference in constitutional jurisdiction.
Appellate Jurisdiction
The Supreme Court is India's apex appellate court. Constitutional appellate jurisdiction arises through Articles:
- 132
- 133
- 134
- 134A
Article 132: Constitutional Appeals
Article 132 concerns appeals from judgments, decrees or final orders of High Courts where the case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution, subject to the constitutional certification framework.
Article 133: Civil Appeals
Article 133 deals with civil appeals from High Courts where the constitutional requirements concerning a substantial question of law of general importance and the need for a Supreme Court decision are satisfied.
Article 134: Criminal Appeals
Article 134 provides specified constitutional routes of appeal in criminal matters. Parliament may also enlarge the Court's criminal appellate jurisdiction by law.
Article 134A: Certificate for Appeal
Article 134A regulates the High Court's consideration of whether a certificate should be granted for an appeal under the relevant constitutional provisions. This certification route should be distinguished from discretionary special leave under Article 136.
Special Leave to Appeal: Article 136
Article 136 gives the Supreme Court a broad discretionary power to grant special leave to appeal. It may operate in relation to judgments, decrees, determinations, sentences or orders made by courts or tribunals in India, subject to the constitutional limitation in Article 136(2).
Article 136 is not an automatic constitutional right of appeal. It is a discretionary jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
Armed Forces Exception
Article 136(2) excludes judgments, determinations, sentences or orders passed or made by courts or tribunals constituted by or under laws relating to the Armed Forces.
π Prelims Trap: Article 136 is extremely wide, but it contains an express Armed Forces-related constitutional exception.
Certificate Appeal vs Special Leave Petition
| Feature | Constitutional certificate route | Article 136 SLP |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional basis | Articles 132, 133, 134, 134A | Article 136 |
| Nature | Appeal through specified constitutional conditions | Discretionary special leave |
| High Court certificate | Relevant to certificate route | Not the basis of Article 136 |
| Automatic admission? | Subject to applicable constitutional requirements | No, Supreme Court decides whether to grant leave |
Review Jurisdiction: Article 137
Article 137 empowers the Supreme Court to review its own judgments or orders, subject to:
- provisions of law made by Parliament, and
- rules made under Article 145
A review petition is therefore constitutionally recognised. It is not equivalent to a regular fresh appeal against the Supreme Court's judgment.
Curative Petition
The Constitution does not expressly use the expression curative petition. The remedy developed through Supreme Court jurisprudence, particularly: Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra
It operates only in exceptional circumstances after the review process has failed to cure a grave defect. The Supreme Court Rules, 2013 contain procedural provisions concerning curative petitions. A curative petition should therefore not be described as:
- an ordinary appeal, or
- a routine second review
Finality of Supreme Court judgments remains the general rule.
Review vs Curative Petition
| Feature | Review Petition | Curative Petition |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional foundation | Article 137 | Judicially developed remedy |
| Stage | After Supreme Court judgment/order | Generally after dismissal of review |
| Nature | Limited reconsideration | Extremely narrow exceptional remedy |
| Rules | Supreme Court Rules | Supreme Court Rules plus curative jurisprudence |
Transfer of Cases: Article 139A
Article 139A permits transfer in specified circumstances. Where cases involving the same or substantially the same questions of law are pending before the Supreme Court and one or more High Courts, or before multiple High Courts, and substantial questions of general importance arise, the Supreme Court may exercise the constitutional transfer mechanism. The provision also permits transfer of cases between High Courts within its constitutional framework.
Law Declared by Supreme Court: Article 141
Article 141 provides: The law declared by the Supreme Court shall be binding on all courts within the territory of India.
This gives Supreme Court precedent a constitutional foundation.
What Is Binding?
The binding principle is the law declared by the Court. UPSC answers should distinguish the binding legal principle from every observation made in a judgment. The doctrinal distinction is commonly expressed through:
- ratio decidendi
- obiter dicta
The legal rule necessary for deciding a case carries the central precedential force.
Article 142: Complete Justice
Article 142 empowers the Supreme Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction, to pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it. Orders and decrees under the Article are enforceable throughout India according to the constitutional framework.
Article 142 is a distinctive constitutional power.
Article 141 vs Article 142
| Article | Core idea |
|---|---|
| 141 | Law declared by Supreme Court binds all courts |
| 142 | Supreme Court may issue orders or decrees necessary for complete justice in a pending cause or matter |
π Prelims Trap: Article 141 concerns binding law. Article 142 concerns the Court's remedial power in matters before it.
Authorities Must Act in Aid: Article 144
Article 144 requires: all authorities, civil and judicial, in the territory of India to act in aid of the Supreme Court. This supports the institutional enforceability of Supreme Court authority.
Advisory Jurisdiction: Article 143
Article 143 enables the President of India to refer specified matters to the Supreme Court.
Article 143(1)
If it appears to the President that a question of law or fact:
- has arisen or is likely to arise, and
- is of such nature and public importance that it is expedient to obtain the Supreme Court's opinion
the President may refer the question to the Court. The Court may, after such hearing as it thinks fit, report its opinion to the President.
Article 143(2)
The Constitution also provides a special reference mechanism concerning disputes of the kind referred to in the proviso to Article 131. In this category, the constitutional language requires the Court to report its opinion after hearing as it thinks fit.
Advisory Opinion vs Judgment in Ordinary Litigation
An Article 143 reference is an advisory constitutional process initiated by the President. It is not identical to an ordinary appeal between private litigants.
π Prelims Trap: Advisory jurisdiction belongs to the Supreme Court under Article 143. A High Court does not exercise an equivalent presidential reference jurisdiction.
Constitution Bench: Article 145(3)
Article 145 is highly important for UPSC. The Constitution requires a minimum of five judges to sit for:
- deciding a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution, or
- hearing a reference under Article 143
Such a bench is commonly called a Constitution Bench. The Court may also constitute larger benches when necessary.
Bench Strength and Precedent
As a general judicial principle, a bench of smaller strength cannot overrule a binding decision of a larger bench. If reconsideration is required, the matter is ordinarily referred to an appropriate larger bench.
Rules of the Supreme Court
Article 145 authorises the Supreme Court, with the approval of the President and subject to parliamentary law, to make rules regulating its practice and procedure. The Supreme Court Rules, 2013, as amended, regulate important procedural matters. This is distinct from Parliament determining the Court's constitutional jurisdiction through provisions where the Constitution authorises legislation.
Judicial Review
Judicial review is the power to examine whether legislative and executive action complies with the Constitution. The Supreme Court's review authority arises from the constitutional structure and multiple provisions, including:
- Article 13
- Article 32
- appellate jurisdiction
- constitutional interpretation
- Article 136
- Article 137
- Article 368 jurisprudence
Judicial review is central to maintaining constitutional supremacy.
Constitutional Supremacy, Not Judicial Supremacy
India follows a written Constitution that binds:
- Legislature
- Executive
- Judiciary
The Supreme Court has final constitutional adjudicatory authority in cases properly before it, but the Court itself derives its jurisdiction and powers from the Constitution. Therefore UPSC answers should avoid reducing the system to a simple contest between "Parliamentary supremacy" and "Judicial supremacy". The broader constitutional structure is one of: constitutional supremacy + separation of functions + checks and balances
Kesavananda Bharati and the Basic Structure Doctrine
In Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, 1973, the Supreme Court held that Parliament's power to amend the Constitution under Article 368 does not extend to destroying its basic structure. This transformed constitutional amendment review.
Parliament possesses a broad amending power, but that power is constitutionally limited. Elements recognised through basic structure jurisprudence include principles such as:
- supremacy of the Constitution
- republican and democratic government
- secularism
- federalism
- separation of powers
- judicial review
- independence of the judiciary
The doctrine has developed across multiple cases and should not be reduced to a single exhaustive list.
Minerva Mills v. Union of India
The Court reaffirmed limits on Parliament's amending power. The judgment emphasised that:
- limited amending power is itself constitutionally significant
- harmony between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles is part of the constitutional balance
The case reinforced the role of judicial review under the Basic Structure doctrine.
L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India
This case is particularly important for the constitutional position of courts and tribunals. The Supreme Court held that the power of judicial review exercised by:
- High Courts under Articles 226 and 227, and
- the Supreme Court under Article 32
forms part of the Constitution's basic structure. Tribunals may perform important adjudicatory functions, but their decisions are subject to constitutional judicial scrutiny according to the framework laid down by the Court.
Judicial Review of Constitutional Amendments
The Supreme Court may review a constitutional amendment to determine whether it violates the Basic Structure. This does not mean every constitutional amendment is invalid merely because it changes an important provision. The constitutional question is whether the amendment damages or destroys a basic feature of the Constitution.
Public Interest Litigation
Public Interest Litigation, commonly called PIL, developed through judicial interpretation and procedural innovation. It relaxed traditional rules of locus standi in appropriate cases so that constitutional courts could address rights violations affecting persons or groups who might be unable to approach the Court themselves.
PIL has been associated with areas such as:
- bonded labour
- prison conditions
- environmental protection
- rights of disadvantaged groups
- access to justice
PIL is not a separate constitutional Article. Its constitutional foundation is linked to the courts' existing jurisdiction, particularly rights enforcement.
PIL and Judicial Restraint
PIL should not be understood as a licence for courts to decide every policy disagreement. The Supreme Court has repeatedly developed principles governing:
- standing
- maintainability
- bona fides
- abuse of process
- separation of institutional functions
For GS-II, a balanced answer should recognise both:
- PIL's contribution to access to constitutional justice
- the need to maintain institutional limits and prevent misuse
Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint
These are analytical expressions, not distinct constitutional jurisdictions.
Judicial Activism
Generally refers to an expansive judicial role in:
- rights interpretation
- constitutional remedies
- development of procedural innovations
- directions where constitutional rights require protection
Judicial Restraint
Emphasises:
- respect for separation of powers
- institutional competence
- limits of judicially manageable standards
- avoidance of substituting judicial preference for lawful policy choices
UPSC answers should avoid treating either expression as inherently correct in every case.
Independence of Judiciary and Separation of Powers
The Indian Constitution does not create an absolutely rigid separation among Legislature, Executive and Judiciary. Instead, it establishes:
- functional separation
- checks and balances
- constitutional accountability
Judicial independence protects courts from improper external influence, while judicial review ensures that governmental power remains within constitutional limits. The Supreme Court has repeatedly recognised independence of the judiciary as part of the constitutional basic structure.
Supreme Court and Federalism
The Court performs an important federal role through:
- Article 131 disputes
- constitutional interpretation
- adjudication of legislative competence
- Centre-State disputes
- review of constitutional emergency action
- interpretation of the Seventh Schedule
- disputes concerning distribution of powers
The Supreme Court is therefore both:
- the apex national court, and
- an important constitutional umpire within the federal system
Supreme Court and Fundamental Rights
Article 32 makes the Supreme Court a direct constitutional forum for enforcement of Fundamental Rights. Its role includes:
- interpreting the scope of Fundamental Rights
- examining restrictions imposed by the State
- issuing constitutional remedies
- reviewing legislation and executive action
Article 32 must be read alongside the wider constitutional role of High Courts under Article 226.
Important Jurisdiction Comparison
| Jurisdiction | Constitutional basis | Core purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Fundamental Rights writ jurisdiction | Article 32 | Enforcement of Fundamental Rights |
| Federal original jurisdiction | Article 131 | Specified Union-State and inter-State disputes |
| Constitutional appeal | Article 132 | Substantial constitutional interpretation questions |
| Civil appeal | Article 133 | Qualifying substantial civil questions |
| Criminal appeal | Article 134 | Specified criminal appellate cases |
| Special leave | Article 136 | Discretionary appeal from courts and tribunals |
| Review | Article 137 | Review of Supreme Court's own judgments/orders |
| Transfer | Article 139A | Transfer of qualifying cases |
| Advisory | Article 143 | Presidential reference |
| Complete justice | Article 142 | Necessary orders in pending causes or matters |
Supreme Court and Election Disputes
Article 71 gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction over disputes arising out of, or connected with, the election of:
- President of India
- Vice-President of India
The Court's role here is constitutionally distinct from ordinary election petitions concerning Members of Parliament or State Legislatures.
Independence Does Not Mean Absence of Accountability
Judicial independence protects adjudication from improper pressure. It does not mean judges or courts exist outside constitutional accountability. The framework includes:
- constitutionally prescribed removal
- reasoned judgments
- open court principles subject to lawful exceptions
- review and larger-bench reconsideration
- parliamentary legislation concerning permitted procedural areas
- constitutional limits on judicial power
Independence and accountability should therefore be understood as complementary constitutional concerns.
High-Yield Constitutional Distinctions
| Question | Correct position |
|---|---|
| Retirement age of Supreme Court judge | 65 years |
| Retirement age of High Court judge | 62 years |
| Present sanctioned Supreme Court strength | 34 including CJI |
| Is Collegium mentioned in Constitution? | No |
| Present Supreme Court Collegium for appointments | CJI + four senior-most Supreme Court judges |
| Formal appointing authority | President of India |
| Removal grounds | Proved misbehaviour or incapacity |
| Removal vote | Majority of total membership + two-thirds present and voting in each House |
| Article 32 | Enforcement of Fundamental Rights |
| Article 131 | Specified federal disputes |
| Article 136 | Discretionary special leave to appeal |
| Article 137 | Review jurisdiction |
| Article 141 | Law declared by Supreme Court binding on all courts |
| Article 142 | Complete justice in pending cause or matter |
| Article 143 | Presidential advisory reference |
| Minimum Constitution Bench | 5 judges |
| Is curative petition expressly in Constitution? | No |
| Is NJAC current? | No |
Prelims Traps
Trap 1: The Constitution fixes the Supreme Court permanently at 34 judges
Incorrect. Parliament determines the number of judges through legislation. The present sanctioned strength is 34 including the CJI.
Trap 2: The Collegium is expressly created by Article 124
Incorrect. The Collegium developed through judicial interpretation of the appointments provisions.
Trap 3: The President independently selects Supreme Court judges
Incorrect as a description of the current constitutional system. The appointment is formally made by the President, but operates through the judicially developed Collegium and governmental appointment process.
Trap 4: Supreme Court judges can be removed by a two-thirds majority alone
Incomplete. Article 124(4) requires:
- majority of the total membership of each House, and
- at least two-thirds of members present and voting in each House.
Trap 5: Article 131 is the Supreme Court's Fundamental Rights jurisdiction
Incorrect. Article 131 deals with specified federal disputes. Fundamental Rights enforcement is primarily associated with Article 32.
Trap 6: Article 136 gives an automatic right to appeal
Incorrect. Special leave under Article 136 is discretionary.
Trap 7: Article 136 applies without any constitutional exception
Incorrect. Article 136(2) contains an exception concerning courts and tribunals constituted under laws relating to the Armed Forces.
Trap 8: Article 141 and Article 142 mean the same thing
Incorrect. Article 141 concerns binding law declared by the Court. Article 142 concerns orders or decrees necessary for complete justice.
Trap 9: Curative petition is expressly provided by Article 137
Incorrect. Article 137 expressly provides review. Curative jurisdiction developed judicially and is regulated procedurally through Supreme Court Rules.
Trap 10: Every Supreme Court case concerning the Constitution requires five judges
Incorrect. Article 145(3) requires at least five judges when a substantial question of law as to interpretation of the Constitution is involved and for Article 143 references. Not every case containing a constitutional provision automatically satisfies this requirement.
Trap 11: Article 32 and Article 226 have identical scope
Incorrect. Article 32 is directed to enforcement of Fundamental Rights. Article 226 also extends to writs "for any other purpose".
Trap 12: NJAC currently appoints Supreme Court judges
Incorrect. The NJAC framework was invalidated in 2015. The Collegium system continues.
Landmark Cases for UPSC
Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, 1973
Established the Basic Structure limitation on Parliament's constitutional amending power.
S.P. Gupta v. Union of India, 1981
Important First Judges Case in the evolution of the judicial appointments process.
Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 1993
Second Judges Case. Established judicial primacy and the foundation of the Collegium system.
Re Presidential Reference, 1998
Third Judges Case. Clarified the institutional Collegium consultation mechanism, including the broader Collegium for Supreme Court appointments.
L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, 1997
Affirmed the constitutional importance of judicial review by High Courts and the Supreme Court and its Basic Structure status.
Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra, 2002
Established the exceptional curative petition mechanism after the review process.
Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 2015
Invalidated the Ninety-Ninth Constitutional Amendment and NJAC framework, restoring continuation of the Collegium system.
GS-II Mains Framework
A question on the Supreme Court can be structured through five dimensions.
Guardian of the Constitution
The Court interprets constitutional provisions and determines the validity of governmental action within its jurisdiction.
Protector of Fundamental Rights
Article 32 provides direct access to the Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights.
Federal Adjudicator
Article 131 enables resolution of specified disputes between constitutional governments.
Constitutional Check
Judicial review enables scrutiny of legislative and executive action against constitutional limitations.
Institutional Independence
Security of tenure, difficult removal, financial protections, appointment jurisprudence and administrative safeguards support judicial independence.
A balanced answer should also consider:
- judicial accountability
- transparency in appointments
- case pendency and access to justice
- institutional restraint
- separation of powers
- consistency and certainty in precedent
Quick Revision
βοΈ Supreme Court: Apex constitutional court of India
π¨βοΈ Strength: 34 judges including CJI
π Retirement: 65 years
ποΈ Appointment: President formally appoints; current system operates through Collegium process
π₯ SC Collegium: CJI + four senior-most Supreme Court judges
π³οΈ Removal: Proved misbehaviour or incapacity; special majority in each House
π Article 32: Fundamental Rights enforcement
π€ Article 131: Federal original jurisdiction
π Article 136: Discretionary Special Leave Petition
π Article 137: Review
βοΈ Article 141: Binding law declared by Supreme Court
β Article 142: Complete justice
ποΈ Article 143: Presidential advisory jurisdiction
π¨βοΈ Constitution Bench: Minimum five judges under Article 145(3)
π Basic Structure: Kesavananda Bharati
π Judicial review: Part of the Basic Structure
β NJAC: Invalidated in 2015; Collegium continues
Frequently Asked Questions
How many judges can the Supreme Court of India currently have?
The present sanctioned strength is 34 judges, consisting of the Chief Justice of India and 33 other judges. The Constitution permits Parliament to regulate the number by law.
What is the retirement age of a Supreme Court judge?
A Supreme Court judge retires at 65 years. A High Court judge retires at 62 years.
Is the Collegium system mentioned in the Constitution?
No. The Collegium system developed through Supreme Court judgments interpreting the constitutional appointments process, particularly the Second and Third Judges Cases.
Who appoints judges of the Supreme Court?
The formal constitutional appointment is made by the President of India. Under the current system, recommendations for Supreme Court appointments originate through the Supreme Court Collegium and proceed through the prescribed Union Government process before presidential appointment.
What is the composition of the Supreme Court Collegium for appointment of Supreme Court judges?
The current institutional process uses the Chief Justice of India and four senior-most judges of the Supreme Court.
What is the difference between Article 32 and Article 131?
Article 32 concerns enforcement of Fundamental Rights. Article 131 gives the Supreme Court original jurisdiction over specified disputes between the Union and States or between States where a legal right is involved.
Is an Article 136 Special Leave Petition a guaranteed appeal?
No. Article 136 gives the Supreme Court discretionary power to grant special leave to appeal. It is not an automatic right of appeal.
What is the difference between Article 141 and Article 142?
Article 141 makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts in India. Article 142 empowers the Court to make orders or decrees necessary for complete justice in a cause or matter pending before it.
What is a Constitution Bench?
Under Article 145(3), at least five judges must sit when a case involves a substantial question of law concerning interpretation of the Constitution or when the Court hears a presidential reference under Article 143.
Can the Supreme Court review its own judgment?
Yes. Article 137 expressly gives the Supreme Court review jurisdiction subject to applicable law and rules.
Is a curative petition mentioned in the Constitution?
No. The curative remedy was developed by the Supreme Court, especially in Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra, and is governed by a highly restricted framework after the review process.
Can Parliament remove a Supreme Court judge by an ordinary majority?
No. Article 124(4) requires a majority of the total membership of each House and at least two-thirds of members present and voting, on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
Is the NJAC currently used for appointment of Supreme Court judges?
No. The Supreme Court invalidated the Ninety-Ninth Constitutional Amendment and the NJAC Act in 2015. The Collegium system continues to operate.
Official Primary References
- Constitution of India, Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice Articles 32, 71, 121, 124 to 147, 368 and related constitutional provisions.
- Supreme Court of India: Jurisdiction Official explanation of original, appellate, Article 136, advisory, review, curative and contempt jurisdiction.
- Supreme Court of India: Appointment of Chief Justice and Judges of the Supreme Court Current institutional appointment process, Supreme Court Collegium composition and process for appointment of the Chief Justice of India.
- Supreme Court of India: Collegium Resolutions Current official publication of Supreme Court Collegium recommendations.
- Supreme Court of India: History Official institutional history, bench structure and sanctioned strength of the Supreme Court.
- Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956, India Code Statutory basis for the sanctioned number of Supreme Court judges.
- Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, India Code Statutory procedure for investigation of alleged misbehaviour or incapacity of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
- Supreme Court Rules, 2013, as amended Rules governing Supreme Court procedure, including review and curative petitions.
- Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, Supreme Court of India Basic Structure doctrine and constitutional limits on the amending power.
- Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 1993 Second Judges Case and development of the Collegium system.
- Re Presidential Reference, 1998 Third Judges Case and clarification of Collegium consultation.
- L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, 1997 Judicial review under Articles 32, 226 and 227 and the Basic Structure.
- Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra, 2002 Constitutional jurisprudence underlying the curative petition.
- Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, 2015 Decision concerning the Ninety-Ninth Constitutional Amendment and National Judicial Appointments Commission.