PolityNovember 20, 2026

Governor, State Government and State Legislature: Powers, Discretion & Article 200 for UPSC

U

UPSC Planner Editorial Team

Summary

A structured UPSC guide to the State executive and legislature: Articles 152 to 213, Governor powers and discretion, Chief Minister, Legislative Council, Article 200 assent, and landmark cases.

The State government is the Union model in miniature, but it works under a very different constitutional logic. The Governor is the constitutional head of the State and a part of its Legislature, the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers run the government, and the Legislative Assembly (with a Legislative Council in some States) makes State law and holds the executive accountable.

For UPSC, this chapter matters because it is the State-side counterpart of the Union chapters on the President, the Prime Minister and Parliament. Almost every question here is a comparison: appointed Governor against elected President, Legislative Council against Rajya Sabha, Article 200 assent against Article 111 assent, Article 213 ordinances against Article 123 ordinances.

This chapter covers Articles 152 to 213 of Part VI: the Governor, the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers, the Advocate-General, the composition and working of the State Legislature, legislative and financial procedure, the Governor's assent and ordinance powers, and leading Supreme Court decisions.


Quick Takeaways

  • Governor: Appointed by the President by warrant under hand and seal (Article 155). The Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President for a normal term of five years (Article 156).
  • Executive power: Vested in the Governor (Article 154) but exercised in practice by the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister (Article 163).
  • Discretion: The Governor acts on ministerial aid and advice except where the Constitution requires action in the Governor's discretion. Discretion is the exception, not the rule.
  • Council of Ministers: Collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly (Article 164(2)). Its size is capped at 15 percent of the Assembly, with a minimum of 12 Ministers (Article 164(1A)).
  • State Legislature: Consists of the Governor and the Legislative Assembly, and in some States a Legislative Council (Article 168). The Governor is therefore a constituent part of the Legislature.
  • Legislative Council: A permanent House created or abolished by Parliament under Article 169 after a special-majority resolution of the Assembly. It is much weaker than Rajya Sabha.
  • Bills: After passage, the Governor may assent, withhold assent, or reserve the Bill for the President (Article 200). A Governor who withholds assent from a Bill other than a Money Bill must return it for reconsideration.
  • Ordinances: The Governor may issue Ordinances when the Legislature is not in session (Article 213). They must be laid before the Legislature and cease six weeks after it reassembles.
  • Constitutional duty on assent: In State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab (2023), the Supreme Court clarified that the expression "as soon as possible" in Article 200 conveys constitutional urgency, and a Governor cannot sit on Bills indefinitely.

High-Yield Exam Facts

  • Article 153: There is a Governor for each State. The same person may be Governor of two or more States.
  • Article 157: A Governor must be a citizen of India and at least 35 years of age.
  • Article 158: A Governor cannot be a member of Parliament or of a State Legislature, and cannot hold an office of profit. Emoluments cannot be diminished during the term.
  • Article 159: The oath is administered by the Chief Justice of the High Court of the State, or in the Chief Justice's absence the senior-most available Judge.
  • Article 161: The Governor can grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions and can suspend, remit or commute sentences for offences against State law.
  • Article 164(4): A Minister who is not a member of the State Legislature for six consecutive months ceases to be a Minister.
  • Article 165: The Advocate-General is appointed by the Governor and must be qualified to be a High Court Judge.
  • Article 170: The Legislative Assembly has not more than 500 and not less than 60 members, subject to special provisions for a few States.
  • Article 171: The Legislative Council has at most one-third of the Assembly's strength and in no case fewer than 40 members.
  • Article 172: The Assembly lasts five years unless dissolved earlier. The Council is not subject to dissolution, and one-third of its members retire every second year.
  • Article 173: Minimum age is 25 for the Assembly and 30 for the Council.
  • Article 174: No more than six months may separate two sessions.
  • Article 199: A Money Bill is certified by the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, whose decision is final.
  • Article 213: An Ordinance ceases at most six weeks after the Legislature reassembles, or earlier if a disapproving resolution is passed.

The Constitutional Framework: Articles 152 to 213

ArticlesSubject
152 to 162The Governor: appointment, term, conditions, oath, pardoning power and extent of State executive power
163 to 167Council of Ministers, Chief Minister, Advocate-General and conduct of government business
168 to 177Constitution, composition, duration, qualifications and sessions of the State Legislature
178 to 187Officers of the Legislature and its secretarial staff
188 to 193Oath, voting, quorum, vacation of seats and disqualification
194 to 195Powers, privileges, salaries and allowances
196 to 201Legislative procedure, Money Bills, assent and reservation of Bills
202 to 207Financial procedure: budget, grants, appropriation and financial Bills
208 to 212Rules of procedure, language, restrictions on discussion and non-interference by courts
213Ordinance-making power of the Governor

Article 152 states that "State" in this Part does not include the State of Jammu and Kashmir. Union Territories are governed by separate provisions and are outside the general State pattern described here.

The Governor

Appointment, term and qualifications

The Governor is appointed by the President by warrant under hand and seal (Article 155). The Governor is not elected and is not chosen by the State Legislature. In practice, the Union Government decides the appointment. Consultation with the State is a matter of convention and recommendation, not a constitutional requirement.

  • Pleasure of the President: Article 156(1) says the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President. The Governor can resign in writing addressed to the President (Article 156(2)).
  • Five-year term: Subject to the pleasure clause, the term is five years from the date of entering office. A Governor continues in office after the term ends until a successor enters office (Article 156(3) and proviso).
  • Qualifications: The person must be a citizen of India and at least 35 years of age (Article 157).
  • Conditions of office: The Governor must not be a member of Parliament or of a State Legislature. If such a member is appointed, the seat is deemed vacated on entering office as Governor. The Governor must not hold any other office of profit (Article 158).
  • Emoluments: Determined by Parliament by law, and until then as specified in the Second Schedule. They cannot be reduced during the term (Article 158(3) and (4)).
  • Same person for two States: The proviso to Article 153 permits one person to be Governor of two or more States, and Article 158(3A) lets the President allocate the emoluments among those States.
  • Oath: Taken before the Chief Justice of the High Court of the State (Article 159).
  • Contingencies: Under Article 160, the President may make provision for the discharge of the Governor's functions in any contingency not provided for in this Chapter.

Can a Governor be removed at will?

The text says the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President, which means the pleasure of the Union Council of Ministers. In B.P. Singhal v. Union of India (2010) 6 SCC 331, a Constitution Bench held that the power of removal is not arbitrary. The President may remove a Governor at any time without notice or assigning reasons, but only in rare and exceptional circumstances and for compelling reasons. A Governor cannot be removed merely because the Governor's views differ from those of the Union Government or the ruling party at the Centre, and a removal order is subject to judicial review.

Executive power and its extent

Article 154 vests the executive power of the State in the Governor, to be exercised directly or through subordinate officers in accordance with the Constitution. Article 162 extends it to matters on which the State Legislature may legislate. For subjects on the Concurrent List, State executive power is subject to and limited by the executive power conferred on the Union by the Constitution or by parliamentary law.

All executive action of the State Government is expressed to be taken in the name of the Governor (Article 166(1)). The Governor makes rules for the convenient transaction of Government business and for the allocation of business among Ministers (Article 166(3)). The Chief Minister must communicate Council decisions and legislative proposals to the Governor, furnish information the Governor calls for, and place before the Council any matter decided by a Minister alone if the Governor so requires (Article 167).

Powers of the Governor at a glance

CategoryPowers
ExecutiveAppoints the Chief Minister and, on the Chief Minister's advice, other Ministers (Article 164); appoints the Advocate-General (Article 165)
LegislativeSummons, prorogues and dissolves the Assembly (Article 174); addresses the House (Articles 175 and 176); assents to Bills (Article 200); issues Ordinances (Article 213)
FinancialCauses the annual financial statement to be laid (Article 202); no demand for a grant or financial Bill without the Governor's recommendation (Articles 203 and 207)
JudicialPardons, reprieves, respites, remissions and commutations for offences against State law (Article 161)
DiscretionaryMatters where the Constitution requires action in the Governor's discretion (Article 163), including reserving certain Bills for the President under Article 200

Pardoning power: Governor against President

PointPresident (Article 72)Governor (Article 161)
Court martial sentencesYesNo
Offences against Union lawYesNo (only offences against State law)
Death sentenceCan pardon, reprieve, respite, remit, suspend or commuteCannot pardon, but Article 72(3) preserves the Governor's power to suspend, remit or commute a death sentence

Discretion and ministerial advice

Article 163(1) provides that there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Chief Minister at the head to aid and advise the Governor, except in so far as the Governor is by or under the Constitution required to act in the Governor's discretion. Two protections follow:

  • If a question arises whether a matter is one for the Governor's discretion, the Governor's decision is final, and the validity of anything done cannot be questioned on the ground that the Governor ought or ought not to have acted in discretion (Article 163(2)).
  • The question whether any advice was tendered by Ministers, and what it was, cannot be inquired into by any court (Article 163(3)).

Article 361 separately provides that a Governor is not answerable to any court for the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of the office, and bars criminal proceedings against a Governor during the term of office. It does not prevent proceedings against the Government of the State.

Typical situations where the Governor exercises real discretion include choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority, reserving a Bill for the President, and reporting that the constitutional machinery in the State has failed under Article 356. Special responsibilities of the Governor under the Article 371 series and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules are further examples.

Chief Minister and Council of Ministers

Appointment and tenure

  • Chief Minister: Appointed by the Governor. Other Ministers are appointed by the Governor on the advice of the Chief Minister. Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the Governor (Article 164(1)).
  • Oath: The Governor administers the oaths of office and secrecy (Article 164(3)).
  • Six-month rule: A Minister who is not a member of the State Legislature for any period of six consecutive months ceases to be a Minister (Article 164(4)).
  • Salaries: Determined by the State Legislature by law (Article 164(5)).
  • Tribal welfare Ministers: The first proviso to Article 164(1) requires a Minister in charge of tribal welfare in Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh and Odisha, who may also hold charge of Scheduled Castes, backward classes or other work.

Size of the Council: the 91st Amendment

The Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003 inserted Articles 164(1A) and 164(1B), effective from 1 January 2004.

ProvisionEffect
Article 164(1A)The total number of Ministers, including the Chief Minister, cannot exceed 15 percent of the strength of the Legislative Assembly
First provisoA State must have at least 12 Ministers, including the Chief Minister
Article 164(1B)A legislator disqualified under the Tenth Schedule is also disqualified from being appointed a Minister until the term of the House would end, or until re-election, whichever is earlier

Collective responsibility

Article 164(2) states that the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. It is the Assembly, not the Council, that holds the executive to account. If the Assembly passes a vote of no confidence, the whole Council must go. The Legislative Council plays no part in this relationship.

Governor and Chief Minister: the floor test

In S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) 3 SCC 1, the Supreme Court held that the strength of a Ministry is to be tested on the floor of the House and not decided by the Governor's own assessment or report. In Rameshwar Prasad v. Union of India (2006) 2 SCC 1, the Court held that the dissolution of the Bihar Legislative Assembly in 2005 was unconstitutional, and that a Governor cannot pre-empt the formation of a government on the basis of unverified allegations of horse-trading.

In Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra (Writ Petition (Civil) No. 493 of 2022, decided 11 May 2023), a Constitution Bench held that the Governor was not justified in calling a floor test on the material before the Governor, because there was no objective material indicating that the Government had lost the confidence of the House. The Court added that the Governor cannot enter the political arena by acting on an inference about disputes inside or between parties, and that internal disagreement within a party is not by itself a ground for a floor test. It did not restore the earlier Government, because the Chief Minister had resigned without facing the test, and it held that the Governor was justified in then inviting the leader of the other group to form the Government.

Advocate-General

The Governor appoints a person qualified to be a High Court Judge as Advocate-General for the State (Article 165(1)). The Advocate-General advises the State Government on legal matters, holds office during the pleasure of the Governor and receives the remuneration the Governor determines. Under Article 177, the Advocate-General and every Minister may speak in and take part in the proceedings of the Assembly and its committees, but cannot vote by virtue of that article.

Union and State Executive: Quick Comparison

FeatureUnionState
Head of the StatePresident (Article 52)Governor (Article 153)
Mode of selectionElected by an electoral collegeAppointed by the President
RemovalImpeachment under Article 61At the pleasure of the President (Article 156)
Executive powerArticle 53Article 154
Aid and adviceArticle 74Article 163
Real executivePrime Minister and CouncilChief Minister and Council
Collective responsibility toLok Sabha (Article 75(3))Legislative Assembly (Article 164(2))
Ordinance powerArticle 123Article 213
Assent to BillsArticle 111Article 200
Pardoning powerArticle 72Article 161
Size cap on Council15 percent of Lok Sabha (Article 75(1A))15 percent of the Assembly, minimum 12 (Article 164(1A))
Law officerAttorney-General (Article 76)Advocate-General (Article 165)

The State Legislature

Composition

The Legislature of every State consists of the Governor and one or two Houses (Article 168(1)). The Legislative Assembly (Vidhan Sabha) is the lower House. The Legislative Council (Vidhan Parishad) exists only in some States. The Governor is a part of the Legislature, which is why Bills need the Governor's assent.

Article 168 lists the States that may have two Houses. The Legislative Council is currently functional in Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Telangana and Uttar Pradesh. The list in Article 168 also names Madhya Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, but no functioning Council exists there at present. For the exam, recall the six functioning Councils and check the latest official source for any change, because Parliament can create or abolish a Council.

Creation and abolition of a Legislative Council: Article 169

Parliament may by law abolish a Council or create one, if the Legislative Assembly passes a resolution by a majority of its total membership and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting. Such a law is not an amendment of the Constitution for the purposes of Article 368 (Article 169(3)), even though it may contain consequential constitutional changes. The State cannot abolish its own Council. Only Parliament can act, and only after the Assembly's resolution.

Legislative Assembly: Article 170

  • The Assembly has not more than 500 and not less than 60 members, chosen by direct election from territorial constituencies in the State.
  • The Constitution makes special provision for a few small States. For example, the Goa Assembly may have not less than 30 members and the Mizoram Assembly not less than 40.
  • Seats are readjusted after each Census by authority and in the manner Parliament determines. Until the first Census taken after 2026 is published, the total number of seats and the division into constituencies remain frozen on the basis of the 1971 and 2001 Census figures as provided in Article 170(3).

Legislative Council: Article 171

  • The Council has not more than one-third of the Assembly's strength and in no case fewer than 40 members.
  • About one-third are elected by local authorities (municipalities, district boards and similar bodies), about one-twelfth by graduates of at least three years' standing, about one-twelfth by teachers of at least three years' standing in institutions not lower than secondary school, and about one-third by members of the Legislative Assembly from among persons who are not its members.
  • The remainder, about one-sixth, are nominated by the Governor from persons with special knowledge or practical experience in literature, science, art, the co-operative movement and social service (Article 171(5)).
  • Elections use proportional representation by the single transferable vote (Article 171(4)).

Duration and qualifications

  • Assembly: Five years from the date appointed for its first meeting, unless sooner dissolved (Article 172(1)). During a Proclamation of Emergency, Parliament may extend the term by law for up to one year at a time, and not beyond six months after the Proclamation ceases to operate.
  • Council: Not subject to dissolution. As nearly as possible, one-third of its members retire on the expiration of every second year (Article 172(2)).
  • Qualifications: Citizen of India, and at least 25 years old for the Assembly or 30 for the Council. The person must also make and subscribe an oath or affirmation before a person authorised by the Election Commission (Article 173).

Sessions, summoning and dissolution

The Governor summons the House or Houses at the time and place the Governor thinks fit, but six months must not intervene between the last sitting of one session and the first sitting of the next (Article 174(1)). The Governor may prorogue the Houses and dissolve the Legislative Assembly (Article 174(2)). By convention and by judicial decision, these powers are exercised on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers.

In Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly (2016) 8 SCC 1, a Constitution Bench held that the Governor's power to summon or advance a session under Article 174 is not to be exercised unilaterally in the Governor's own discretion, and the Governor's discretion under Article 163 is limited. A seven-judge reference on part of that decision (the effect of a notice to remove the Speaker on disqualification proceedings) was made in Subhash Desai.

Governor's address and messages

  • The Governor may address the Assembly, or both Houses assembled together, and may require members' attendance (Article 175(1)).
  • The Governor may send messages about a pending Bill or otherwise, and the House must consider the matter with all convenient despatch (Article 175(2)).
  • At the commencement of the first session after each general election to the Assembly and at the commencement of the first session of each year, the Governor addresses the Legislature and informs it of the causes of its summons (Article 176).

Presiding Officers

Speaker and Deputy Speaker

The Assembly chooses a Speaker and a Deputy Speaker from among its members (Article 178).

  • Vacating: A Speaker or Deputy Speaker vacates the office on ceasing to be a member, may resign in writing, and may be removed by a resolution passed by a majority of all the then members of the Assembly, after at least 14 days' notice (Article 179).
  • Dissolution: When the Assembly is dissolved, the Speaker does not vacate the office until immediately before the first meeting of the next Assembly (Article 179 proviso).
  • During a removal motion: The Speaker does not preside while a resolution for removal is under consideration, but may speak and take part, and may vote only in the first instance, not in the case of a tie (Article 181).
  • Casting vote: The Speaker does not vote in the first instance but has a casting vote in the case of equality (Article 189(1)).

Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Council

The Council chooses a Chairman and a Deputy Chairman from among its members. The removal rules mirror those for the Speaker (Articles 182 to 185). Unlike the Vice-President, who is the ex officio Chairman of Rajya Sabha, the Chairman of the Legislative Council is elected from among the Council's own members.

Conduct of Business, Disqualification and Privileges

  • Oath of members: Taken before the Governor or a person appointed by the Governor (Article 188).
  • Voting: Questions are decided by a majority of members present and voting, excluding the presiding officer, who votes only to break a tie (Article 189(1)).
  • Quorum: Ten members or one-tenth of the total membership of the House, whichever is greater, until the State law provides otherwise (Article 189(3)).
  • Vacancies: A House can act despite vacancies, and proceedings are not invalid because an ineligible person sat or voted (Article 189(2)).
  • Dual membership: A person cannot be a member of both Houses of a State Legislature, or of the Legislatures of two or more States (Article 190(1) and (2)).
  • Absence: If a member is absent from all meetings for sixty days without permission, the House may declare the seat vacant. Days of prorogation or adjournment for more than four consecutive days are not counted (Article 190(4)).
  • Penalty for unqualified sitting: A person who sits or votes before taking the oath, or knowing the person is unqualified or disqualified, is liable to a penalty of five hundred rupees for each day (Article 193).

Disqualification

Article 191(1) lists the grounds: holding an office of profit under the Government of India or a State Government (other than an office exempted by State law), unsoundness of mind declared by a competent court, being an undischarged insolvent, not being a citizen or voluntarily acquiring foreign citizenship, and disqualification by or under a law of Parliament. Article 191(2) adds disqualification under the Tenth Schedule.

Who decides?

GroundDeciding authority
Article 191(1) groundsThe Governor, after obtaining the opinion of the Election Commission and acting according to that opinion (Article 192)
Defection under the Tenth ScheduleThe Speaker or Chairman of the House, subject to judicial review

Compare this with Parliament, where Article 103 gives the President the power to decide, after obtaining the Election Commission's opinion, a question of disqualification under Article 102(1). Article 192 is the State equivalent.

Privileges

There is freedom of speech in the Legislature, subject to the Constitution and the rules of procedure (Article 194(1)). No member is liable to proceedings in any court for anything said or any vote given in the Legislature or any committee (Article 194(2)). Other powers, privileges and immunities are as defined by State law and, until then, as they stood immediately before the coming into force of section 26 of the Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978 (Article 194(3)).

Legislative Procedure

Ordinary Bills

  • In a State with a Council, an ordinary Bill may originate in either House (Article 196(1)). To be passed, it must be agreed to by both Houses, subject to Article 197.
  • Lapse: A Bill pending in the Legislature does not lapse on prorogation. A Bill pending in the Council that the Assembly has not passed does not lapse on dissolution of the Assembly. A Bill pending in the Assembly, or passed by the Assembly and pending in the Council, lapses on dissolution of the Assembly (Article 196(3) to (5)).

How weak is the Legislative Council?

Under Article 197, if the Council rejects an ordinary Bill passed by the Assembly, does not pass it within three months, or amends it in a way the Assembly does not accept, the Assembly may pass the Bill again. If the Council then again rejects it, does not pass it within one month, or amends it unacceptably, the Bill is deemed passed in the form the Assembly passed it the second time. The Council can therefore only delay an ordinary Bill by a maximum of about four months. There is no joint sitting.

Money Bills: Articles 198 and 199

  • A Money Bill cannot be introduced in the Legislative Council (Article 198(1)).
  • After the Assembly passes it, the Bill goes to the Council for recommendations, which the Council must return within 14 days. The Assembly may accept or reject any of them (Article 198(2) to (4)).
  • If the Council does not return the Bill within 14 days, it is deemed passed in the form the Assembly passed it (Article 198(5)).
  • Article 199 defines a Money Bill as one containing only the matters it lists, such as taxation, borrowing, the Consolidated Fund and appropriation. The Speaker's decision on whether a Bill is a Money Bill is final, and the Speaker's certificate is endorsed on the Bill (Article 199(3) and (4)).

Assembly against Council: key differences

PointLegislative AssemblyLegislative Council
MembersDirectly electedIndirectly elected and nominated
ExistenceEvery StateOnly some States, created or abolished by Parliament under Article 169
DurationFive years unless dissolvedPermanent, one-third retire every second year
Council of Ministers responsible toYes (Article 164(2))No
Money BillsIntroduces and decidesRecommendations only, within 14 days
Ordinary BillsFinal say after the second passageCan delay by about four months in total
Voting on demands for grantsYesNo
Presiding officerSpeaker, elected from membersChairman, elected from members
Role in electing the PresidentElected members voteMembers do not vote

Legislative Council against Rajya Sabha

PointRajya SabhaLegislative Council
Created byThe ConstitutionParliament by law, on Assembly resolution (Article 169)
Relationship to the other HouseCo-equal on ordinary Bills, with a joint sitting under Article 108Subordinate, with no joint sitting
Special powersArticle 249 (State List), Article 312 (All India Services)None
StrengthFixed by the ConstitutionAt most one-third of the Assembly and not fewer than 40
Presiding officerVice-President is ex officio ChairmanChairman elected from the Council

Assent to Bills: Articles 200 and 201

What the Governor can do

When a Bill has been passed by the Assembly, or by both Houses where there is a Council, it is presented to the Governor, who shall declare one of three things (Article 200):

  1. that the Governor assents to the Bill;
  2. that the Governor withholds assent; or
  3. that the Governor reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President.

The first proviso permits the Governor, as soon as possible after the Bill is presented, to return a Bill that is not a Money Bill with a message asking the House to reconsider it, and to suggest amendments. If the House passes the Bill again, with or without amendment, and it is presented again, the Governor shall not withhold assent.

The second proviso makes reservation mandatory in one case: the Governor shall not assent to, but shall reserve for the President, any Bill that in the Governor's opinion would so derogate from the powers of the High Court as to endanger the position the Court is designed to fill.

What the President can do

When a Bill is reserved, the President declares that assent is given or withheld (Article 201). For a Bill that is not a Money Bill, the President may direct the Governor to return it to the House with a message. The House must then reconsider it within six months. If it is passed again, with or without amendment, it must again be presented to the President for consideration.

Why reservation matters in the Concurrent List

Article 254(2) allows a State law on a Concurrent List subject that is repugnant to an earlier parliamentary law to prevail in that State, if it has been reserved for the consideration of the President and has received the President's assent. This is why Article 200 and Article 254 must be read together. Parliament may still later legislate on the same matter.

The Supreme Court on Governor's assent

  • State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab (2023 INSC 1017, decided 10 November 2023): A three-judge Bench headed by the Chief Justice of India held that the expression "as soon as possible" in Article 200 conveys a constitutional imperative of expedition. A Governor cannot sit on Bills indefinitely. Where assent is withheld from a Bill that is not a Money Bill, the Governor must return it to the Legislature with a message for reconsideration under the first proviso to Article 200. Withholding assent without returning the Bill is contrary to the constitutional scheme. If the House passes the Bill again, with or without amendment, the Governor cannot withhold assent.

Financial Procedure: Articles 202 to 207

ArticleProvision
202The Governor causes a statement of estimated receipts and expenditure (the annual financial statement) to be laid before the Legislature for every financial year
203Expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund is discussed but not voted. Other expenditure goes as demands for grants to the Assembly, which may assent, refuse or reduce. No demand is made except on the Governor's recommendation
204Appropriation Bill authorises expenditure from the Consolidated Fund
205Supplementary, additional or excess grants
206Votes on account, votes of credit and exceptional grants
207A financial Bill or amendment on the matters in Article 199(1)(a) to (f) needs the Governor's recommendation and cannot be introduced in the Council. A Bill involving expenditure from the Consolidated Fund cannot be passed unless the Governor has recommended its consideration

The Assembly alone votes on demands for grants. The Council can only discuss the budget. This is a key marker of how the Council differs from Rajya Sabha, which also does not vote on demands for grants but participates in discussion.

Ordinance-Making Power: Article 213

Conditions

The Governor may promulgate an Ordinance when the Legislative Assembly is not in session, or when neither House of a bicameral Legislature is in session, and the Governor is satisfied that circumstances exist which make immediate action necessary (Article 213(1)).

Instructions from the President

The Governor cannot promulgate an Ordinance without the President's instructions if (a) a Bill with the same provisions would have needed the President's previous sanction for introduction, (b) the Governor would have thought it necessary to reserve a Bill with the same provisions for the President, or (c) a State Act with the same provisions would be invalid unless reserved for and assented to by the President.

Life of an Ordinance

  • It has the same force and effect as an Act of the Legislature assented to by the Governor (Article 213(2)).
  • It must be laid before the Assembly, or both Houses where there is a Council, and ceases to operate at the expiration of six weeks from reassembly, or earlier if a resolution disapproving it is passed by the Assembly and agreed to by the Council, if any. Where the Houses reassemble on different dates, the six weeks are counted from the later date.
  • The Governor may withdraw it at any time.
  • Any provision that would not be valid in an Act assented to by the Governor is void (Article 213(3)).

In D.C. Wadhwa v. State of Bihar (1987) 1 SCC 378, the Supreme Court held that repeatedly re-promulgating Ordinances without placing them before the Legislature is a colourable exercise of power and a fraud on the Constitution.

Governor Against President: High-Yield Prelims Traps

  • Trap 1: The Governor is not elected by the people or the Legislature. The President appoints the Governor.
  • Trap 2: The Governor's term of five years is not a fixed tenure. The Governor serves during the pleasure of the President.
  • Trap 3: The Governor is a part of the State Legislature. This is why the Governor's assent is needed for State Bills.
  • Trap 4: The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly alone, not to the Legislative Council.
  • Trap 5: The Governor can suspend, remit or commute a death sentence but cannot pardon it. Article 72 gives the President that power exclusively, with Article 72(3) preserving the Governor's other powers.
  • Trap 6: The Governor can return a Bill for reconsideration, but if it is passed again the Governor cannot withhold assent. The Governor can still reserve certain Bills for the President.
  • Trap 7: A State cannot abolish its own Legislative Council. Parliament does it by ordinary law after the Assembly's special-majority resolution, and that law is not an amendment under Article 368.
  • Trap 8: The Legislative Council is a permanent House but is not co-equal with the Assembly. The Council cannot block a Bill beyond the delay in Article 197 and cannot reject a Money Bill.
  • Trap 9: The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor, not elected by the Legislative Assembly, although the Governor must appoint the leader who commands the confidence of the House.
  • Trap 10: The Governor, not the Speaker, decides disqualification under Article 191(1), but only after obtaining and following the Election Commission's opinion. Defection under the Tenth Schedule is decided by the Speaker.
  • Trap 11: The Governor's discretion is not general. Article 163 allows discretion only where the Constitution requires it, and Nabam Rebia (2016) held that the Governor cannot use discretion to summon or advance a session on the Governor's own.

Mains Analytical Dimensions

1. The Governor's dual role

The Governor is both the constitutional head of the State and an agent of the Union. This dual position creates recurring friction when the State and the Centre are governed by different parties. A balanced answer should separate the formal powers in the text from the conventions of aid and advice, identify the narrow area of real discretion, and cite Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab (1974) 2 SCC 831, where the Supreme Court held that the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers except in the limited cases where the Constitution requires discretion.

2. Assent, delay and legislative autonomy

The recent litigation over Bills awaiting assent raises a federal question: how can a State Legislature's law-making be protected from indefinite delay while respecting the constitutional office of the Governor? The 2023 Punjab decision stressed constitutional expedition and the mandatory duty to return a withheld Bill for reconsideration. A balanced answer should examine the tension between gubernatorial scrutiny and legislative supremacy, citing institutional solutions such as Sarkaria Commission guidelines.

3. Floor tests and political crises

The cases from S.R. Bommai to Rameshwar Prasad to Subhash Desai establish that the Governor is not an arbiter of political disputes. The Governor's role in inviting a leader to form a government, summoning the House and ordering a floor test must be anchored in objective material and the constitutional scheme, not partisan preference.

4. Bicameralism in the States

The Legislative Council is defended as a House for expertise and for representing graduates, teachers and local bodies, and criticised as a delaying House and a route for political accommodation. Its weak constitutional position (no vote on Money Bills, no role in the confidence relationship, no joint sitting) supports the argument that States can function well with a single House.

5. Ordinances as a legislative substitute

The ordinance power is meant for genuine urgency. Re-promulgation, the use of Ordinances to bypass the Legislature and the lack of scrutiny during recess are recurring concerns, which D.C. Wadhwa addressed directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who appoints and removes the Governor?

The President appoints the Governor by warrant under hand and seal (Article 155), and the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President (Article 156). In B.P. Singhal v. Union of India (2010), the Supreme Court held that removal must be for compelling reasons and is subject to judicial review.

Is the Governor bound by the advice of the Chief Minister?

Yes, ordinarily. Article 163(1) requires the Governor to act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister, except where the Constitution requires the Governor to act in the Governor's discretion. Discretion is the exception.

Can the Governor withhold assent to a Bill permanently?

No. Under Article 200, a Governor who withholds assent from a Bill that is not a Money Bill must return it to the House for reconsideration. If the House passes it again, the Governor cannot withhold assent. The Supreme Court in State of Punjab (2023) affirmed that a Governor cannot sit on Bills indefinitely.

Can a Governor issue an Ordinance at any time?

No. Article 213 permits an Ordinance only when the Legislature is not in session, when immediate action is necessary, and subject to the conditions that require the President's instructions in certain cases. It ceases six weeks after the Legislature reassembles unless disapproved earlier.

What is the difference between the Rajya Sabha and a Legislative Council?

Rajya Sabha is created by the Constitution, is co-equal with Lok Sabha on ordinary Bills and has special powers under Articles 249 and 312. A Legislative Council exists only where Parliament has created it under Article 169, has at most one-third of the Assembly's strength, and can only delay ordinary Bills and make recommendations on Money Bills.

Who decides a question of disqualification of a State legislator?

For the grounds in Article 191(1), the Governor decides after obtaining the opinion of the Election Commission and acting according to it (Article 192). For defection under the Tenth Schedule, the Speaker or Chairman decides, subject to judicial review.

How many Ministers can a State have?

Not more than 15 percent of the strength of the Legislative Assembly and not fewer than 12, including the Chief Minister, under Article 164(1A) as inserted by the Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003.

Official Primary References